Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine by The Killers is an evocative narrative steeped in mystery and emotional intensity. The song delves into themes of innocence, guilt, and dramatic encounters. Through its storytelling, it appears to describe a protagonist being questioned by authorities about the disappearance or harm of a woman named Jenny, who they claim was merely a friend. Some poignant moments arise when the singer conveys a sense of desperation and defense, asserting their innocence. This track reflects the band's knack for crafting compelling narratives through their lyrics.