Andy, You're A Star by The Killers is a song that delves into themes of admiration, longing, and unrequited love. The protagonist seems to be expressing admiration for someone named Andy, who is likely a high school sports star or a popular figure. The song captures the intensity of feeling and the complexity of emotions when one idolizes someone from afar. Key themes include hero worship, the struggles of concealing feelings, and the bittersweet nature of infatuation. The line 'In a car with a girl, promise me she's not your world' poignantly captures the protagonist's internal conflict and desire for recognition from Andy.