Selective Memory by Eels is a poignant reflection on the theme of memory and the emotional pain of forgetting and remembering. The song delves into the concept of choosing which memories to retain and which to forget, a process that often comes with a significant emotional burden. It explores the struggles and sorrow associated with past relationships, suggesting a desire to escape the pain by selectively remembering only the good times. Key themes include coping with loss, emotional resilience, and the bittersweet nature of nostalgia. Particularly poignant moments in the song arise when the lyrics express the deep longing to cling to cherished memories while grappling with the inevitability of forgetting.