Why Do I Keep Counting? by The Killers delves into themes of anxiety, existential reflection, and the search for meaning. Through poignant lyrics, the band explores the feeling of being overwhelmed by life's uncertainties and the struggle to find a sense of control. The song's protagonist repeatedly asks why they keep counting, symbolizing their attempt to quantify and understand their worries. Notable moments include introspective questions and the yearning for reassurance, reflecting a deep desire for stability and peace in the face of unpredictability.